Debt: the First 5,000 Years
by David Graeber
The primary purpose of Debt: the First 5,000 Years is to correct the historical record concerning the origin of barter, coinage and credit. Incredibly well researched, anthropologist David Graeber’s book is a fascinating read. I found it extremely helpful in gaining some understanding of modern problems with debt and perpetual war. I was particularly intrigued to learn about the 2,600 year old link between war, debt and money creation, as well as the role of violent insurrection in shaping history. Ruling elites are terrified of insurrection. Throughout history, this fear has driven most major reforms.
Debunking Adam Smith
The conventional wisdom, which originates from Adam Smith’s Wealth of Nations, is that money (i.e. coins) originated out of barter relationships, and that paper money and credit replaced coins when trade became too large and complex to be conducted with coins. As Graeber ably demonstrates, Smith had it backwards. Not only was barter virtually non-existent in prehistoric societies, but coinage itself was an extremely late development. Virtual credit preceded coinage (and barter) by thousands of years in all early civilizations. What’s more, these complex credit-debt arrangements played a vital role in the development of traditional institutions, such as slavery, patriarchy, urbanization and organized religion.
The Myth of Barter
People didn’t barter in early hunter gatherer and agrarian societies because they didn’t need to. Well into the Middle Ages, basic needs were met by family and community mutual obligation networks. There was an expectation extended family, neighbors would provide what you couldn’t provide for yourself.
There was a vital need for credit, however, with the development of farms large enough to feed the entire community. According to archeological evidence, credit first developed around 5,000 years ago when farmers borrowed seed and farm implements from wealthy merchants and repaid the debt with a share of the harvest. When the harvest failed, they repaid it in sheep, goats and furniture. When that was gone, they sold their children and eventually themselves into slavery.
This scheme was difficult to enforce, as many indebted farmers either walked away from their land or launched violent insurgencies. In was for this reason that both Sumeria and early Chinese civilizations launched formal debt forgiveness schemes, in which people regained their lands and debt slaves were free to return to their lands.*
The first money (in the form of precious metals, shells or other tokens) was used to pay the bride price the groom paid the bride’s family, the blood debt incurred when someone was murdered and to buy someone out of slavery.
The Origin of Patriarchy
In the earliest Sumerian texts (3000-2500 BC), women appear as doctors, merchants, scribes and public officials and are free to participate in all aspects of public life. This changes over the next 1000 years, with women becoming closeted to protect the honor of their fathers and husbands. According to Graeber, this pressing need to protect a woman’s reputation arose from a reaction by agrarian peoples (such as the early Israelites) to urbanization and the prostitution that resulted from it. The rise of cities in Sumeria and Babylon was accompanied by the rise of numerous informal occupations – including prostitution – practiced by men and women who had fled slavery. Patriarchy arose simultaneously in ancient China for similar reasons.
War, Debt and Money
Coinage (gold, silver and bronze coins) arose simultaneously between 600 BC and 800 AD (aka the Axial Period) in Greece, Rome, the great plains of northern China and the Ganges Valley for precisely the same reason: it was impossible to finance war with local systems of credit.
In all three civilizations, the first coins were used to pay professional soldiers (aka mercenaries). This would lead to the first market economies, as soldiers spent their coins in local communities, as well as concepts of profit and debt interest. In fact, a vicious cycle was established whereby rulers tried to solve their debt problems through expansionist wars to acquire more land, resources and slaves. In every case, this strategy backfired and the wars only increased their indebtedness.
The appearance of coins and market economies also led to a backlash against materialism and preoccupation with money. All the world’s major philosophic tendencies (Zoroastrianism, Buddhism, prophetic Judaism, Hinduism, Confucianism, Jainism, Taoism, Christianity and Islam) arose during the Axial Period
This period also saw the rise of the first peace movements when early philosophers (eg Socrates and Plato) made common cause with rebels who opposed the violence of war and existing power relationships. According to Graeber these movements were remarkably successful in reducing the brutality and frequency of war. By 600 AD, slavery itself was virtually non-existent.
The Rise and Fall of Credit Economies
Following the fall of Rome, populations fled the cities and lived in smaller communities that reverted to credit economies. Gold and silver were used for temples and cathedrals, and only rich people had access to coins. All the major religions prohibited usury.
Money lending and banking arose to fund the Crusades, with the Knights Templar replacing Jewish moneylenders. After their persecution, torture and extermination by Phillip IV (due to the enormous debt he owed them), the latter were replaced by Venetian and Genoan bankers. The Italian bankers used municipal and government debt bonds as the chief instrument of exchange.
Around 1450, gold and silver bullion and coin (much of it from the New World) were re-introduced to finance vast empires and predatory warfare. This development was accompanied by the return of usury and debt slavery.
The Birth of Capitalism
Graeber defines capitalism as a gigantic credit/debt apparatus pumping maximum labor out of human beings to produce an ever expanding quantity of material goods. He dates its origin to around 1700 (six years after the Bank of England issued the first paper banknotes). Police, prisons and state sanctioned slavery were essential tools in achieving the phenomenal productivity needed to finance political systems based on continual war.
*”Every seventh year you shall make a cancellation. The cancellation shall be as follows: every creditor is to release the debt he has owing to him by his neighbor” (Deuteronomy 15:1-3). Every 49 years came the Jubilee, when all family land was to be returned to its original owners, and even family members who had been sold as slaves set free (Leviticus 25:9).
Kind of curious if Mr. Graeber made any suggestions or conclusions with regard to alternative monetary systems moving forward.
No, he didn’t. He seems to come to the conclusion that humanity tends to operate in cycles, shifting between a credit economy and a money economy based on war, debt and urbanization. He seems to have a deterministic outlook that we are on the downward cycle of a slope that’s trending away from centralization and urbanization towards regional centers that will be based more on credit and mutual trust. He suggests this historical trend explains why many contemporary activists are taking up decentralization, war and debt as key issues.
Complementary currencies is a subject worth reading as Bernard Lietaer is a prolific author on the subject.
It is the most prevalent oversight, and is the “blind spot” for most economists and career professionals.
Monetary architecture as a tool for societal evolution.
Having a diversity of alternative and complementary currencies in the community would produce resiliency and creativity in transitioning into a liberating meme of prosperity.
Personal sovereignty is rarely researched and offered as the alternative to institutional control and domination.
I look for us to embrace the personal sovereignty meme and remember that
Money Is An Agreement.
I think New Zealand has progressed pretty well along this path. Many towns (including New Plymouth) have both time banks and a mutual credit system (LETS) through the South African website https://www.community-exchange.org/
“Ruling elites are terrified of insurrection. Throughout history, this fear has driven most major reforms.”
Maybe this means there is hope for us? 🙂
Absolutely. According to Graeber, that’s the only thing that works – threat of insurrection.
Very interesting book and I love the detail you give in your review – or rather summery.
Thanks, Skywalker. It really is more a summary than a review. However it’s only a small glimpse of an extensive period of history. Hopefully I provided enough detail to inspire people to read a truly brilliant book.
Sounds like a very informative book. Thank you.
auntyuta says: “Ruling elites are terrified of insurrection. Throughout history, this fear has driven most major reforms.”
Maybe this means there is hope for us?
stuartbramhall says: Absolutely. According to Graeber, that’s the only thing that works – threat of insurrection.
“Every seventh year you shall make a cancellation. The cancellation shall be as follows: every creditor is to release the debt he has owing to him by his neighbor” (Deuteronomy 15:1-3).
Every 49 years came the Jubilee, when all family land was to be returned to its original owners, and even family members who had been sold as slaves set free (Leviticus 25:9).”
Just to share this…
Sep 24, 2009 Iceland – https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jvg55YveGfI
Jul 22, 2012 – The man who changed Iceland – the message for Greece – https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YH0_JQW–gc
Jul 29, 2012 – Bankers Arrested In Iceland, Ireland, UK, USA, Switzerland, India, France, Russia, Austria..- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dmOZ3jtGtCc
Sep 23, 2012 – How Iceland defeated the Anglo-American Bankster Mafia – https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7zlzC_XMQzI
Jan 26, 2013 – Davos – https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DDexDNn6vSM
You be the judge.
Jubilee is essential to any economic system based on credit and debt (which is all of them). Otherwise collapse of your economic system is inevitable. Graeber also emphasizes this in his book.
Thanks for all the great links.
Reblogged this on One Tawny Stranger.
This is a great post. With all that being said in this article I will like to add a liitle bit to this. The notions of Debt, Credit, Slavery, Money Exchange, Barter, Capitalism, Domestication, War and others came as a result of man disunity with Nature. Everything that we are fighting for based on natural wealth was and still given for free by The Most High Creators. So many things happened prior to six thousand years ago but this last six thousand years has been remarkable in recent human history. Due to our disunity with Nature we as a collective have become Egonomics, Egosystems instead of our original states of Economics and Ecosystems.
I know that we can achieved anything if and when we live in harmony with Nature. Mother Nature always have our backs, we are her children. Mother Nature gave us the insight of having Common Wealth, Freedom and Prosperity for all. Natural Law, Moral Law, Universal Law, Maat Law, Commercial Law, Common Law are intertwined, envisioned in the Universal Cosmic Law.
Observing and practicing our daily lifes rooted in the above principles/laws were the ways of the Ancient and Ancestors are encouraging us to to do.
Thanks for the post once again
This is very profound, Omoagbametala. I’ve always had the sense the more civilized society becomes the worse life becomes for ordinary human beings.
Thank you sir
Funny enough Graeber does touch on that. He describes an economic theory called the Primordial Debt Theory, which states that part of the ethos of early civilisation is that humans are in debt since birth. In fact our existence IS debt, primarily to the gods (which can only be repaid properly by dying) but also to other people. Also, debt was synonymous with guilt & sin.
If true, Christianity makes a whole lot more sense (born in sin = born in debt to God; repayment = self-sacrifice which Jesus supposedly paid). It also explains why Judaism, Christianity, Hinduism and other religions were so big on sacrifice.
I’ve now got it. Only read the first 4 chapters so far but already I’m hooked! My gf loves it too!
Pingback: The Hidden History of Money, Debt and Organized Religion | The Most Revolutionary Act
Pingback: Follow The Money: How The Monetary System Is Rigged To Enslave Humanity | The Most Revolutionary Act
Pingback: David Graeber: How Debt Enslaves Us | The Most Revolutionary Act