Tipping Point: The Gilets Jaunes/Yellow Vests are winning, what’s next?

David Studdert

The weekend just gone, Manifestation 23, marked a seismic shift in the five month battle between the Gilets Jaunes and the French state. The Notre Dame fire has brought into the open the strategic shift in public opinion that has occurred over the winter; shifts all to the advantage of the Gilets Jaunes. While the cold winter months with their looming darkness only allowed us to glimpse two equal parties grinding away at each other in the gloom, the advent of spring and its clear light, reveals how the Gilets are gathering reserves of strength all over France, and how, now, they are slowly winning in Paris as well. The sight of French police surrounding Notre Dame and denying access to its ‘own’ population, starkly illustrates what the state seeks to deny. After all, these sort of monuments are the materiality through which states demonstrates their connection to the population, their right to rule and their own power.

The Neo-liberal state is crumbling and Macron is going be the sacrificial lamb. At this stage he will be lucky to last two months. His clumsy handling of the Notre Dame blaze has outraged and enraged more sections of the French population. Indeed throughout the five months of protest, and despite the wall to wall media propaganda, opinion polls consistently show continued and unwavering sympathy and support of the Gilets Jaunes.

In the sharp light of spring it is clear that Macron’s winter strategy: the Great National Debate, has achieved nothing for the government and more tellingly perhaps, has further revealed Macron’s own incapacity to either change himself or shift course. As one anonymous French state official reportedly said: ‘Mitterrand gave them an extra week’s holiday, but Macron can’t manage anything’. He simply seems unable in any form to communicate with either the Gilets or the people of France. His constant speeches, with their casual insults and lack of empathy, remain one of the best recruitment tools the Gilets possess.

His recent pronouncements continue this trend. His promise to rebuild the cathedral in five years was met with scorn – ‘this is not a railway line’, said one commentator, while his invitation to the world (a typical empty gesture) angered and aroused traditionalists. Indeed, as has been widely reported, his endorsement of cash donations from billionaires, simply provided the Gilets with yet more free sticks to beat him and the state.

Even his big showpiece speech was cancelled when the Cathedral burst into flames. And what was his big announcement? A freeze on hospital and school closures, the index-linking of pensions to inflation and the closing of the École Nationale d’Administration (ENA), the university that produces the country’s political and civil elite, all of which, particularly the last, were seen as too late and totally irrelevant. After all it doesn’t put food on the table or help the people get to the end of the month with any money. As I noted in previous articles, this is typical of Macron, revealing only how his personal authority is slipping away, and strangely enough, how irrelevant he is becoming to the entire debate.

Above all, Macron is guilty of being one of those stupid/intelligent middle class people; the sort neo-liberalism delights in providing for us in many guises: administrators, legacy media editors, heads of departments, councillors, politicians. He is bright, he is buffed, he has aspiration, he can speak fluently on subjects for hours, yet for all of that, every speech he makes simply inflames the situation. And this, coupled with his inability to convey a shred of empathy and his apparent lack of understanding concerning both politics and national history, reveal him to be nothing so much as a messenger boy for the rich and the powerful. Once again none of this escapes the French population […]

Source: Tipping Point: The Gilets Jaunes are winning, what’s next?

6 thoughts on “Tipping Point: The Gilets Jaunes/Yellow Vests are winning, what’s next?

  1. Well the only thing that I can say about all of this is that at least the French have gonads since they can start a Movement and actually sustain it for some length of time when all Americans do is march down the street for a day and then go back to moaning and whining over their plight. Without putting any effort into effecting change, change will not take place. And simply voting for dog no. 1 or dog no. 2 has already shown itself to be completely ineffective. Not to mention that not one candidate that is running for the Office of the President in the upcoming 2020 election stands out at all, particularly among the Democrats and since I have not heard of any candidates from the Republican party running against Trump, we will more than likely see a second Trump term. The Democrats are already dead in the water.


    • It grieves me to say it, Shelby, but I suspect too many Americans are still too comfortable to risk their creature comforts to engage in mass rebellion. Americans are still too focused on their own individual needs to even worry about their children and grandchildren.


  2. They need to consolidate. They need to follow-through. They need to jerk the chicken-shit MAcron, from his office by his collar .
    They will have to now, use their power to effectively keep going.

    The arrogant bastard macron said today, he is going after journalists who reported on yemen


  3. Another 6 years of fuko-the demon clown, will guarentee apocolypse. Its wat the kornpone nazis and fanatics want. A small-tactical nuke war w Iran that goes big. 400 nuclear rwactors around the world going off, worse-than Fukushima style. The end. put an end to fuko now. Call washington, demand impeachment. Even w pence the sure road to apocolypse will not necessarily be followed.
    Time for yellow vests here but too many numbbrained morons


    • The House can only impeach Trump, Cammie. It’s the Senate that has to try him and remove him from office. Do you really think it likely that Senate Republicans will do that? I don’t think the Democrats want to impeach him unless they’re sure the Republican Senate will follow through.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.