The Rohyngya Crisis: Is Myanmar the New Syria?

For nearly a year now, the western media has been flooding us with images of Muslim Rohingya fleeing Rakhine state in Myanmar. Since October 2017, an estimated 700,000 (roughly half the Rohingya population) have fled into Bangladesh where they live in primitive refugee camps or in the open air on the roadside. Most of are women fleeing the Myanmar army, which has been burning their villages, gang raping them, killing their husbands and, in some cases, their children. Since 2016, some of the 700,000 Rohingya who remain in Myanmar having been living in camps (some under military force – others voluntarily for protection from Buddhist vigilantes).

We read occasional vague references to the current “civil war” in Rakhine state. And listen to hysterical rants by Amnesty Internationali spokespeople condemning Myanmar president Aung San Suu Kyi for her failure to speak out against the army’s brutal treatment of Rohingya Muslims. AI is also calling for Burmese leaders in the International Criminal Court – which is impossible as Myanmar isn’t an ICC member.

Is a New Proxy War Brewing in Myanmar?

In most cases, the western media tells us virtually nothing about the civil war that is the root cause of the current Rohingya refugee crisis. Why not? In exploring non-western media accounts, I get the uncomfortable inkling I am witnessing a burgeoning proxy war in Myanmar, similar to the civil war in Syria, with Saudi Arabia and possibly other US client states supporting the Rohingya rebels. Obviously this background in no way justifies recent terrorism by the Myanmar army against Rohingya civilians. At the same time, the world is growing weary of the US and their allies using human rights violations as justification for military intervention. In Myanmar, as in Syria, the only sustainable solution is a political settlement, ie an international agreement that protects Rohyngya autonomy and human rights while ending interference by foreign players.

Myanmar’s 70-Year Civil War

The current Rohyngya crisis was triggered in August 2017 when the Arakanii Army (AA) and the Arakan Rohingya Salvation Army (ARSA), a new extremist group, launched a concerted attack on Myanmar army and police. The government of Myanmar has been fighting armed Rohingya separatists since it first won independence in 1948. During World War II when Japan occupied Burma, local Buddhists supported the Axis forces and the Bengali Muslims remained loyal to the British crown. Tens of thousands died during mass mutual reprisals. As Burma negotiated independence from the UK, Muslims in northern Arakan appealed to East Pakistan (now Bangladesh) to annex this area. When the both Burmese independence hero Aung San and Pakistan’s founder Muhammed Ali Jinnaha rejected this appeal, Arakan Muslims launched a mujahideen insurgency

Simultaneously fighting communist and ethnic insurgencies among the Karensiii, the Kachensiv and other marginalized groups, the Burmese army could only control major cities and towns in Arakan. The mujahideen controlled large parts of rural Arakan, leading many Buddhist villagers to flee to the southern part of the state.

It wasn’t until late 1954 that the last mujahideen camps fell to the Burmese army, with most insurgents retreating into East Pakistan. The Burma/East Pakistan (Bangladesh) border has always been extremely porous (like the border between Afghanistan and Pakistan) with Rohingya militants moving in and out of northern Burma to launch attacks on police and army outposts.

Two years after Burma’s 1962 military coup, Muslim youth from rural Arakan formed an underground movement called the Rohingya Independence Force (RIF). In 1998 various RIF factions united to form the Arakan Roningya National Organization (ARNO). It was at this point they began receiving financial and material support from the International Islamic Relief Organization (IIRO), which operates out of Saudi Arabia.

The Rise of the Arakan Army

The 2004 downfall of Prime Minister Kihn Nunt and the collapse of his military intelligence network would result, in 2012, in the emergence of the Arakan Army (AA). Recruiting Rakhine laborers working in Phakant jade plants in Kachine state, the AA agreed to open a new western front in Rakhine state when the ceasefire between the Myanmar military and the Kachine Independence Army (KIA) broke down in 2013, Between March 2015 and April 2016, the AA killed 13 Myanmar troops, which, in turn, captured 57 AA troops.

At present, the government estimates there are 300 AA and ARSA troops operating along the Myanmar-India-Bangladesh border and another 200 fighting with the KIA. They enjoy strong support from the civilian population. Rohingya refugees describe young villagers picking up clubs, knives and sticks to join attacks against Myanmar police and military.

Saudi Support and the Methamphetamine Trade

According to the Muslim World League website, the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia continues to support the Rohingya with financial and material support. According to International Crisis Group, Rohingya separatists also get major financial support from wealthy Rohingya refugees living in Saudi Arabia.

Rohingya militants also seem to be involved in methamphetamine smuggling, with the army seizing 26.7 million meth tabs from suspected militants in 2015 and 37.7 million tablets in 2017. There are also concerns they may have links with the Pakistani Taliban and possibly Islamic State militants.


i Amnesty International is increasingly playing a cheerleading role for US military intervention in Syria and non-aligned countries exhibiting “human rights” violations. See Amnesty International: Trumpeting for War . . . Again

ii Arakan (now known as Rakhine state) is a historic region bordering the Bay of Bengal to its west, Bangladesh to its north and Myanmar to its east.

iii The Karen, Kayin, Kariang or Yang people encompass a number of individual Sino-Tibetan language speaking ethnic groups, many of which do not share a common language or culture. These Karen groups reside primarily in Karen State, in southern and southeastern Myanmar.

iv The Kachins are a coalition of six tribes whose homeland encompasses territory in Yunnan, China, Northeast India and Kachin State in Myanmar.

I originally published this article in OpEd News

(Image by Tasnim News Agency [CC BY 4.0 (creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0)], via Wikimedia Commons)

11 thoughts on “The Rohyngya Crisis: Is Myanmar the New Syria?

    • And the media pressure has gotten much worse since I published the article, Tammy. The UN has come out now labeling the Rohynga crisis genocide and calling for the Security Council to pursue prosecution in the International Criminal Court (which they say China will veto – though as usual they don’t explain this either).

      And now the UN is condemning ethnic cleansing of the Kachens (a Christian minority) and the Uighers in China.

      And US senators are calling for sanctions on the Chinese for their treatment of the Uighers. It all seems too coincidental – coming as it does in the midst of a giant US trade war with China.

      Like

  1. Dr. Bramhall, thanks for sharing this background info to the conflict in Myanmar. It does, indeed, sound like another Syria in the making. Based on the BBC world news reports, the plight of the Rohingya people is the entire fault of the Burmese military.

    Liked by 1 person

    • Rosaliene, I’m coming to think the only way to unravels this type of situation is to take a step back and take a serious look at the fallout of European colonization – and to decide what real decolonization would look like. I heard an excellent talk by Ward Churchill last week (which I will post tomorrow) which got me thinking about this.

      Like

  2. Over a year ago ISIS had sent in over 500 terrorists to stir things up for the forthcoming round of death and destruction, many of the exiles who had lived there since the British brought them in as slave labour, fled the terrorists explaining what was going on to independent journalists, but many still remain. One can assume that the terrorists now number far more than a mere 500 since that time. Unfortunately Myanmar president Aung San Suu Kyi is unable to control much of the military and that military presence has shown themselves capable of obscene, murderous brutality and until there is unity among the Burmese army, monstrous acts of barbarity from both sides of the conflict will continue. The terrorists who flooded in a year ago have succeeded in creating a sub culture in their own image and worsening the already hostile situation that has existed for so long. As usual Britain caused the problem and resentments and then promptly walked a way leaving the problem unresolved without any attempt to take accountability for what they had done in the name of Imperialism and plunder. The only solution has to be diplomatic, but it will need boots on the ground to monitor both sides and interject where necessary, the UN, however, is unlikely to intervene, as it serves the Imperialist warmongering capitalist cabal.
    Thanks for this article, it is an extremely important read.

    Like

    • Thanks for your extremely thoughtful comment, Myanmar, and for the link. Excellent point about counting the number of separatists – this is impossible because they all disappear into Bangladesh when you try to count them.

      I am very please to have the link – I think I saw this article about a year ago but couldn’t find the link when I came to write the article.

      And thanks for reblogging my post.

      Like

  3. I give you this link as an accompaniment, although I’m sure you will have already seen it. It’s from OffG by Georoid O Colmain and it’s title is “The Rohingya Psyops:Waging Covert War on Myanmar. It’s an article I printed and forgot to include the web link.
    I also found one other article by Asia Times for which I do have the link:
    http://www.atimes.com//article/truth-behind-myanmars-rohingya-insurgency/?utm_source=The+Daily+Brief&utm_campaign=c5d5f91204-EMAIL_CAMPAIGN_2017_09_20&utm_medium=email&utm_term=0_1f8bca137f-c5d5f91204-31510313
    Good to know that this latest war is getting coverage.

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.